What is The Mechanics of Convertible Note Conversion?
Mathematical Foundation
Laws & Principles
- The 'Best of Both Worlds' Protocol: The investor does not get BOTH the discount and the cap stacked. The math is calculated under both mechanisms separately. The investor receives shares at whichever price is lower, maximizing their equity stake.
- The Post-Money Cap Trend: Many modern Y-Combinator SAFEs use 'Post-Money' caps, which lock in an exact ownership percentage (e.g., $1M on a $10M Post-Money cap guarantees a 10% stake) and force the founders to absorb 100% of the dilution.
- Accrued Interest Dilution: Because convertible notes are technically debt instruments, they accumulate interest (typically 5-8% APR). If it takes a startup 3 years to reach a priced round, this accumulated interest converts alongside the principal into more shares, diluting the founders more than anticipated.
Step-by-Step Example Walkthrough
" A seed investor puts $100,000 into a startup via a convertible note with a $5M Valuation Cap and a 20% Discount. Two years later, the startup raises a Series A at a $10M Pre-Money Valuation with a $1.00 Series A share price. "
- 1. Calculate the Discount Price: $1.00 × (1 - 0.20) = $0.80 per share.
- 2. Calculate the Cap Price: $5M Cap / $10M Pre-Money = 50%, so $1.00 × 0.50 = $0.50 per share.
- 3. Compare: The Cap Price ($0.50) is better for the investor than the Discount Price ($0.80).
- 4. Apply Interest: 8% simple interest over 2 years → $100k + $16k = $116,000 total.
- 5. Convert: $116,000 / $0.50 per share = 232,000 shares issued to the seed investor.