What is Internal Rate of Return — The PE Gold Standard?
Mathematical Foundation
Laws & Principles
- The Hurdle Rate Gate: Calculating IRR alone is insufficient. You must compare it to the Hurdle Rate (usually WACC). If IRR > Hurdle Rate, the project creates value. If IRR < Hurdle Rate, the project destroys value. The IRR tells you the yield; the hurdle rate tells you if that yield is worth the risk.
- The Sign-Change Requirement: IRR requires at least one negative cash flow and at least one positive cash flow. Without opposing cash directions, the polynomial equation has no real root — the calculator cannot find a breakeven discount rate.
- The Reinvestment Assumption Flaw: Standard IRR assumes every interim cash flow is reinvested at the IRR rate itself. If your project yields 40% IRR but you reinvest interim cash at 4% in a savings account, the realized return is significantly lower than IRR suggests. Use MIRR to correct this.
Step-by-Step Example Walkthrough
" A real estate developer buys a lot for $100,000 (Year 0). The property generates $10k, $20k, $30k, $40k in Years 1–4, and is sold for $50k in Year 5. "
- Total raw cash out: -$100,000.
- Total raw cash in: $10k + $20k + $30k + $40k + $50k = $150,000.
- The algorithm tests discount rates: 5% leaves NPV positive, 15% pulls NPV negative.
- Newton-Raphson converges on 12.01% — the rate where NPV = $0.00.