What is Protecting Motors Against Thermal Destruction?
Mathematical Foundation
Laws & Principles
- FLA vs. FLCC: Always size the overload device based on the exact motor nameplate 'Full Load Amps' (FLA), not the generalized tables in NEC 430.248/250 used for wire sizing.
- The 1.25 Multiplier Rule: Motors engineered with higher quality insulation (Service Factor 1.15+) or robust cooling (Temp Rise 40°C max) dissipate heat effectively and are safely permitted to run slightly overloaded (in the 'Service Factor margin') for intermittent periods. The NEC grants a generous 125% trip cap.
- The 1.15 Multiplier Rule: Cheaper 'standard' motors (Service factor 1.0, high temp rise) do not have a safety margin. If they exceed their FLA they rapidly cook their insulation. They are strictly capped at 115% FLA trip points.
- Modification: If the motor still stalls and refuses to start without tripping the overload, NEC 430.32(C) permits an absolute maximum bump to 140% for the robust motors and 130% for standard motors—but doing so voids the warranty and severely limits the motor's lifespan.
Step-by-Step Example Walkthrough
" An industrial plant receives two different 10 HP motors. Motor A is an expensive Severe-Duty model (FLA 24A, 1.15 SF). Motor B is a cheap off-brand replacement (FLA 26A, 1.0 SF). Both need thermal overload protections sized. "
- 1. Motor A check: Nameplate shows Service Factor 1.15. This triggers the higher 125% allowance.
- 2. Motor A math: 24A × 1.25 = 30.0 Amps max trip.
- 3. Motor B check: Nameplate shows Service Factor 1.0. This restricts it to the tight 115% allowance.
- 4. Motor B math: 26A × 1.15 = 29.9 Amps max trip.