What is Geometric Dimensioning & Tolerancing: True Position?
Mathematical Foundation
Laws & Principles
- The Bonus Tolerance Myth: Coordinate ± tolerances create a square zone. The corners of that square are further from the center than the flat sides. True position eliminates these corners, creating a uniform circular zone. However, it effectively gives you 57% MORE allowable deviation in the diagonal directions than strict coordinate dimensioning.
- The CMM ×2 Trap: Coordinate Measuring Machines (CMMs) naturally report radial deviation (how far the center point missed the target). Engineering drawings specify diametric tolerance zones. You MUST multiply your calculated hypotenuse by 2. Forgetting this means you are accepting parts that are twice as bad as the blueprint allows.
- Maximum Material Condition (MMC): If the blueprint callout includes an (M) symbol, you get 'bonus tolerance'. If your hole is drilled larger than its smallest allowable size (its MMC limit), you can add that extra diameter to your allowable True Position zone. A nominally 'failed' hole can actually pass if it was drilled slightly oversized.
- Datum Reference Frames: True position is meaningless without datums. The deviations (ΔX and ΔY) must be measured from the exact coordinate system established by the Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary datums called out in the feature control frame.
Step-by-Step Example Walkthrough
" An inspector measures a drilled hole on a CMM. Nominal location is X: 5.000', Y: 3.000'. Actual measured location is X: 5.004', Y: 2.997'. The drawing specifies a positional tolerance of ⌀0.010'. Does it pass? "
- 1. Calc X deviation: 5.004 - 5.000 = +0.004'.
- 2. Calc Y deviation: 2.997 - 3.000 = -0.003'.
- 3. Square the deviations: (0.004)² = 0.000016. (-0.003)² = 0.000009.
- 4. Add them: 0.000016 + 0.000009 = 0.000025.
- 5. take Square Root (Radial deviation): √0.000025 = 0.005'.
- 6. Multiply by 2 for Diameter: 0.005' × 2 = 0.010'.