What is Protecting Motors Against Thermal Destruction?
Mathematical Foundation
Laws & Principles
- FLA vs. FLCC: Always size the overload device based on the exact motor nameplate 'Full Load Amps' (FLA), not the generalized tables in NEC 430.248/250 used for wire sizing.
- The 1.25 Multiplier Rule: Motors engineered with higher quality insulation (Service Factor 1.15+) or robust cooling (Temp Rise 40°C max) dissipate heat effectively and are safely permitted to run slightly overloaded (in the 'Service Factor margin') for intermittent periods. The NEC grants a 125% trip cap.
- The 1.15 Multiplier Rule: Standard motors (Service factor 1.0, high temp rise) do not have this thermal margin. If they exceed their FLA they rapidly degrade their winding insulation. They are strictly capped at 115% FLA trip points.
- Modification: If the motor still stalls during starting without clearing the overload, NEC 430.32(C) permits a maximum threshold bump to 140% for robust motors and 130% for standard motors.
Step-by-Step Example Walkthrough
" An industrial plant receives two different 10 HP motors. Motor A is an expensive Severe-Duty model (FLA 24A, 1.15 SF). Motor B is a cheap off-brand replacement (FLA 26A, 1.0 SF). Both need thermal overload protections sized. "
- 1. Motor A check: Nameplate shows Service Factor 1.15. This triggers the higher 125% allowance.
- 2. Motor A math: 24A × 1.25 = 30.0 Amps max trip.
- 3. Motor B check: Nameplate shows Service Factor 1.0. This restricts it to the tight 115% allowance.
- 4. Motor B math: 26A × 1.15 = 29.9 Amps max trip.